Caldwell Cigar Co. "The King is Dead" Review: A Top 25 Cigar That Never Lost Its Luster

After more than a dozen years of being in business, it's safe to say that Caldwell Cigar Co. is here to stay. Not only has the boutique brand rocketed to stardom thanks to collaborative blends with the likes of AJ Fernandez and Matt Booth, but the whole Lost & Found Series has taken "cigar recycling" to a whole new level.

But it wasn't just a series of collabs and salvaged cigar blends that got Robert Caldwell and his crew to this point. Not even a year after launching the boutique brand, the cigar-making startup had already secured a Top 25 status for one of its blends over at Cigar Aficionado. An oddly named smoke with an avant-garde band called The King is Dead, which relied upon a super rare tobacco strain for its wrapper, and an equally unusual filler and binder internal blend. 

Caldwell Cigar Co. "The King is Dead"

This oddball concoction starts with a Dominican "negrito" wrapper. A varietal that is notorious for not playing nice with other tobacco strains, but looks outstanding when utilized correctly. Naturally,  Robert Caldwell was hell-bent on taming this leafy beast, and so a corojo binder was placed underneath, followed by a modest mixture of ligero corojo, a pinch more negrito, and then a hefty bunching of HVA 202/20. 

Over the next dozen years, this winning tobacco combo would help keep the economic pistons pumping for Robert Caldwell's cigar-oriented operations. Along with this smoke's immensely popular sidekick, Long Live the King, Mr. Caldwell slowly but surely secured his place as one of the more adventurous next-generation blenders in the biz. 

Unlit Impressions 

Caldwell Cigar Co. "The King is Dead" Review

Sitting somewhere between hickory brown and Rosado-colored, the negrito wrapper on the outside of this blend instantly earns points for the cigar even before it is lit. Shiny, but not overly oily, this rarity of a tobacco strain feels just as smooth under the thumb as it does beneath the eye. Seams take a moment to detect and are snugly fitted, with leaf veins following suit. Build quality feels equally good, with a tiny bit of spring ensuring a clear draw. The torpedo cap is a bit misshapen on one side, but is nothing too obscene. 

Aromatherapy junkies will get a jolt of smoky hardwood, leather, potting soil, and a mildly sweet, faintly spiced finish. Nothing too engaging, but not an unpleasant experience by a long shot either. Like most cigars, the foot is a far more intriguing area, with scents of cedar mulch, smoked sea salt, caraway seeds and corn chips, oiled leather, and an unusual spicy-and-sweet scent that is difficult to identify.

Unlit cold draws primarily focus upon oiled leather and vintage books, with more soil, a kiss of cocoa, and dried mulled wine spices. Things gradually grow creamier the more you pull, with a pleasant sweetness building deeper within the blend. 

As for the band, while it isn't as captivating as the snazzy design emblazoned upon Long Live the King or some of Caldwell's other bands, it gets the job done. Personally, I like that it is neither overly gaudy nor nondescript like so many other pieces of paper that get placed on stogies. From a graphic designer's standpoint, I find the split throne to be a nice touch, as it is instantly identifiable but also classically styled.

Caldwell Cigar Co. "The King is Dead" Review

Digging the Sound of This Cigar? You Might Also Like...

Caldwell Cigar Co. "Long Live the King"

Warped Cigars "Sky Moon"

Sancho Panza "Extra Fuerte"


Initial Smoke

 Caldwell Cigar Co. "The King is Dead" Review

Seconds after sparking this smoke up, those mulled wine spices circle in, along with some strong notes of cedar, salt, and a generic wholegrain cereal of some sort. Vintage leather is also present, as is a mildly spicy retrohale that leads the senses toward some sweeter cereal grain notes. The draw is perfect, smoke production is near-perfect, and the texture of the fluffy stuff is medium in body.

1st Half

Caldwell Cigar Co. "The King is Dead" Review Creamier and cocoa-like, with a Japanese white bean paste aftertaste, the sweeter side of the cigar shows itself early on in the first third. As lightly toasted wholegrain bread crisps beneath tabs of salted butter, retrohales mellow and spiced herb tea notes are allowed to expand. The latter of these is very much corojo-based, so that binder and the select ligero leaves inside are doing a damn good job of keeping up with that wrapper.

Keeping with that medium-bodied, medium-strength mixture, the second third starts with a touch of farmyard funk, and then moves into some heavier hardwood flavors. Before long, more soil and a sappy, cedar-strong finish form, and the cigar seems to settle on moving toward medium-full in flavor. Spice levels are still very much manageable, and this makes the strength of the cigar seem lower than it surely is.

2nd Half

Caldwell Cigar Co. "The King is Dead" Review Although the tasting wheel does not change all that much for the next thirty minutes or so, the continuation of everything found in the first half of the cigar is pleasant. The only notable addition is that of herb salt-dusted popcorn, which may sound odd, but somehow it works well with everything else being tasted at the time.

Get into the final third, and the blend grows brighter in character, with roasted tea notes and a floral finish being top tasting points. Retrohales remain resinous and cedar-forward, with very little sign of the cigar going dark or heavy in any way. It's a mighty fine moment in the blend that doesn't let you down, even though it may seem a tad tame to some smokers. 

Parting Puffs

Caldwell Cigar Co. "The King is Dead" Review

A final round of flavors occurs once the band is removed, with roasted chicory root and a spicier, sappier spin on cedar smells making retrohales a touch toasty. Smoke textures turn dry at this point, with clay-like soil and a bright finish adding another grade of complexity to the blend. Not bad, but not phenomenal either. 

Ash / Burn / Smoke / Draw

Caldwell Cigar Co. "The King is Dead" Review

Although the ash that built in the first third of the cigar was nothing short of tremendous, ash drops and ash flake became an issue later on. Still, there never once was the need for a torch touch-up, and the overall flow pulled through the point end of the torpedo was near-perfect. Body may never have moved beyond medium-plus, but this magnitude felt perfectly at home on the tongue, with very little seeming out of place anywhere along the way.

Final Thoughts

 Caldwell Cigar Co. "The King is Dead" Review

Although the tobacco blend that makes The King is Dead possible may lead you to believe that you are in for an outrageously wild smoking experience, I found the cigar itself to be fairly formal in nature. Even when the spicier moments later on forced me to reach for my adult beverage, I did not find myself standing back in shock. This is a medium smoke in every regard, and a damn fine one at that. 

Smooth and oily, but also creamy, cocoa-like, and creatively concocted, the delivery of tastes and smells from this unorthodox blend is very enjoyable and easily repeatable. I am also a sucker for a figurado, so getting to review this blend in "Last Payday" torpedo format made the experience all the more enjoyable and memorable. 

I was surprised to find that the cigar was not nearly as cocoa-forward or dark in nature as some claim it to be, with a balanced mixture of cedar, light soil, hardwood, and corojo leaf being the most consistent tastes. This not only makes the cigar far more compatible with a wide array of beverages, but it also prevents it from becoming too oppressive in potency during the warmer months of the year. Perhaps that's why Robert Caldwell was so determined to tame that rarity of a tobacco leaf and then turn it into a wrapper...

Caldwell Cigar Co. "The King is Dead" Review

Flavor, Aroma & Transitions4.5
Depth & Complexity4.5
Construction, Burn & Physical Appeal4.5
Backstory & Branding4.0
Overall Balance & Repeatability4.5

Stogie Specs

CigarCaldwell Cigar Co. "The King is Dead'
WrapperNegrito (Dominican Republic)
BinderCorojo (Dominican Republic)
FillerCorojo Ligero, HVA 20/20 & Negrito (Dominican Republic)
FactoryDominican Republic
Size6″ x 52 (torpedo)
StrengthMedium
Pairing DrinkDon Papa Baroko Rum Highball
Rating4.4/5

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.