Celebrate the year’s finest with our penultimate Best Reviewed Cigars of 2025 collection — now available in one exclusive pack. Inside, you’ll find 12 of the highest-rated cigars from a full year of expert reviews. This pack brings together the most enjoyable smokes of the year in one unbeatable lineup. We’re especially proud of this one…

Crux Cigars "Bull & Bear" - The premium tobacco mix, which is hand-made with an antique Nicaraguan Habano wrapper, offers flavors of peppery spice, cocoa chocolate, and smoky cedar to smokers. Read more

Oscar Valladares "Island Jim Connecticut No. 2” - This cigar's tobacco blend hasn't been disclosed, but it offers a medium body and good, strong tobacco flavors. It has juicy fruit, butter, and light pepper flavors. Read more

Dapper Cigar Co. "El Borracho Natural" - Notes of citrus, semi-sweet chocolate, licorice, and cedar are all present in this full-bodied, box-pressed blend. Translated to "The Drunkard," this smoke has a darker San Andrés wrapper from Mexico. Read more

German Engineered Cigars "Raumzeit" - This stick is characterized by a light silky, fragrant wrapper. It combines aromas of nuts, honey, cream, stardust, white pepper, cloves, and nutmeg providing a sweet and complex experience. Read more

La Palina "125 Años" - Smokers can expect rich flavors of cedar, earth, and dark chocolate, with notes of pepper and spice for a balanced finish. This collaboration honors the centenarian histories of both La Palina and Oliva, creating a truly special cigar. Read more

Jake Wyatt "Icarus" - This bold blend takes flight with the rare use of Tennessee fire-cured tobacco. Wrapped in a toffee-colored San Andrés maduro and built around a Dominican Olor binder with Piloto Cubano, expect notes of cedar, leather, and molasses layered with mesquite, spice, and roasted coffee. Read more

Plasencia "Alma del Campo" - This cigar showcases the purity and depth of Nicaraguan soil through a medium-bodied profile that’s both refined and complex. Expect creamy notes of cedar, vanilla, and toasted pecan over a base of cocoa and earth, with gentle hints of cinnamon spice and dried fruit emerging. Read more

Caldwell "The T. Maduro" -Layered notes of dark fruit, cocoa, roasted cashews, and cedar, with pepper and spice framing a creamy, mocha-leaning core. This Nicaraguan collaboration between Caldwell, Room101, and AJ Fernandez offers a rich but balanced maduro experience. Read more

Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust "Sobremesa Brûlée" - For those who prefer light to medium-bodied cigars with loads of milk and honey flavor. Sobremesa Brûlée comes covered in a smooth Ecuadorian Connecticut wrapper leaf, a Mexican binder, and Nicaraguan filler mix. Combined, these offer an incredibly creamy flavor profile. Read more

Casdagli Cigars "Brothers of the Sabre Epicurist" - A balanced, medium-bodied profile marked by layers of herbal tea, citrus, and cashew cream, evolving into notes of honeyed toast, paprika spice, and sweet brown sugar. Wrapped in an oily Colorado leaf and adorned with Casdagli’s striking cobalt band, the Epicurist honors its Napoleonic namesake. Read more

Cavalier Genève "BII Viso Jalapa" - Made with a Viso Jalapa wrapper and all Habano internals, this Nicaraguan puro delivers a full-bodied experience rich in earth, spice, and cocoa notes, with a long, smooth finish. Read more

Crowned Heads "La Imperiosa" - This full-bodied cigar features a dark, oily Ecuadorian Habano Oscuro wrapper encasing a blend of Nicaraguan binder and filler tobaccos. Expect a rich and complex smoking experience with notes of espresso, cream, and subtle sweetness. The cigar's construction delivers a smooth draw and even burn throughout. Read more