Quesada "Casa Magna Colorado" Review: Revisiting the First Non-Cuban Cigar of the Year

For years, the annual "Top 25 Cigars" ranked within Cigar Aficionado Magazine revolved heavily around Cuban blends, with a sprinkling of "new world" blends occasionally landing a well-deserved slot. And while smokes from non-Cuban countries did manage to crack the Top 25, the coveted #1 spot was always Cuban. But then, in 2008, a blend called the Casa Magna Colorado from Quesada Cigars took "Cigar of the Year," and readers realized that a premium cigar blend didn't have to be Cuban or expensive to be crowned king.

At the time, this medium-powered tobacco cocktail was still being produced by Plasencia, even though Quesada had its own Dominican operations. This was likely due to the fact that the tobacco blend is entirely Nicaraguan, including the wrapper leaf, which was, and still is, a Cuban-seed, shade-grown specimen. Keeping cultivation, fermentation, production, and packaging within the same vicinity made for a far more affordable final product, with a modest $5.25 price point for the award-winning robusto vitola being referenced at the time. 

However, the accolades didn't stop there, with the Casa Magna Colorado making multiple Top 25 appearances within the folds of CA's glossy pages in the upcoming years. The salomon figurado ranked as #12 in 2009, followed a year later by the Churchill in 2010, which came in at #24. But after this three-year winning streak, the blend began to receive some mediocre scores from the publication, with construction and off-flavors plaguing certain vitolas. While some sticks ranked higher than others, with 90+ point ratings being most commonly seen on figurado sizes, it would not be until 2022 that the robusto would earn Quesada a #20 position, and a seat in the winner's circle once again. 

After looking over all of the Casa Magna Colorado reviews conducted by Cigar Aficionado, one major variation in the cigar's spec sheet stands out, and that is the fact that from 2023 onward, Quesada has been producing this blend in-house. It's still the same lineup of tobacco leaves, but it's now rolled down in the Dominican Republic. Having burned through around a dozen different versions of this blend since its launch in 2008, I recently decided it was time to revisit the former #1 Cigar of the Year and give it another go. Not just because I have always been impressed by this smoke, but so that I could see if this shift in production methods had any influence on performance or smoking pleasure.  

Quesada Casa Magna Colorado $44.69 $49.16
Wrapper
Cuban-Seed Shade-Grown Colorado (Nicaragua)
Binder
Nicaragua
Filler
Nicaragua
Origin
Dominican Republic

Unlit Impressions

Quesada "Casa Magna Colorado" Review

 

I, for one, am not that big of a fan of the traditional "Cubanesque" cigar band look, but on this blend it works well. While this cigar, and numerous other blends within the Quesada collection, have yet to undergo the whole rebranding process that has been put into action, the golden sheen on the Casa Magna cigar band seems well-suited to the sharp wrapper sitting underneath.

That shade-grown leaf is just as Cuban in its roots, and embodies a healthy amount of oil within that colorado rosado hue. Veins are large in sections but create some contrasting allure, with a flat spot near the band on my review cigar being the only major imperfection. My sample stick was near-perfect though, as were the other cigars I have smoked in the past, so I feel this stick was the outlier in the group. 

Anyone who is hankering for some sweet smells had best skip the wrapper and head straight down to the foot, because that outer leaf is all oily leather, sour fermented dankness, and salted peanut shells. It's not that the foot is all that mesmerizing; it's just a notch sweeter, with light brown sugar, split bamboo, and raw walnut being my primary takeaways each time. Like the wrapper, this exposed end of the cigar is not very revealing, so skipping to a cut and a cold draw is not a bad idea.

Here, you will discover that the unlit tobacco tastes of lemon and ginger, sour fermentables that make me think of kombucha a little bit, apricot, cedar sawdust, more oily leather, and a nice finish that is sweeter than anything else. Flow rates feel fantastic from a punch, which, after lighting up, proves to be a wise decision.

Quesada "Casa Magna Colorado" Review

Digging the Sound of This Cigar? You Might Also Like...

Crux "Limitada"

Cavalier Genève "Inner Circle Domaine Rouge"

Raices Cubanas "Liga de Reyes"


Initial Smoke

 Quesada "Casa Magna Colorado" Review

Medium doses of spicy cedar, crushed tree nuts, orange zest, and a sweet-and-sour flavor that is vinegar barbecue sauce in nature open the blend up as soon as I set down my torch. Like a good piece of smoked Q, there's a brown sugar rub taste in there too, with a marvelous draw and a medium-length finish mimicking the body of the smoke. It's a relatively creamy taste and texture, with zero sharpness or heat, and as the first third commences, complexity gradually grows.

1st Half

Quesada "Casa Magna Colorado" Review 

Wisps of hickory smoke on the wind, dark fruit compote, sweet, creamy almond milk, and a savory, oily center section slowly elevate the magnitude of the cigar to a new level before long. There's still some sour fermented funk on the backend, but it fits right in with these top notes, and the smoked barbecue flavors of sugar, salt, spice, and hickory make the retrohales and the finish incredibly tantalizing. 

Right around where the second third begins, a transition can be found, with nutty nougat and vanilla wafer cookies making the largest movement. Sweet lassi tea, with its winning mixture of yogurt, milk, sugar, and cardamom powder and saffron, settles in afterward, which adds a touch more body to the already oily, medium-weight smoke. Retrohales manage to detect a pinch more spice than usual, with the cardamom and fermented yogurt sourness being the easiest to find, followed by a hint of rose water and spicy cedar.

2nd Half

Quesada "Casa Magna Colorado" Review 

Savory and sophisticated, the grill rages on, with spicier sauce tastes and smells making the sweeter sides of the cigar work all the harder to maintain a balance. Those brown sugar tastes may get a good amount of caramelization in the center of the stick, but it seems to fit fluidly into the evolution of the cigar, as the oiliness of the smoke's textures takes you closer to the final third.

By the time you do finally get to this last major section of the cigar, the lassi tea has turned even creamier and nuttier. This can be felt best when retrohaled, and the roastiness that follows is not a touch hot or spicy. Textures are oily but not heavy, and there's a balanced bitterness that makes the heavier leather tastes and savory tasting notes feel even more complex. Further down, just as the blend begins to reach the parting puffs phase, a medicinal, mineral-like taste makes its move, throwing one last lick of a transition at you before moving on.

Parting Puffs

 Quesada "Casa Magna Colorado" Review

Although the body has remained medium for much of the time, flavors have gradually grown in number and magnitude, with the tea tastes inside of the smoke being a key player. But parting puffs spike the punch even further, with a liberal amount of roasted chestnut sweetness and medicinal herbs standing out the most. Retrohales also get a bit spicy here, with Spanish cedar being the main aromatic. Body is still medium, though, and every draw taken feels purposeful and well-played all the way until the last puff.

Ash / Burn / Smoke / Draw

 Quesada "Casa Magna Colorado" Review

Jutting burn lines tend to be a given every time I spark up a Casa Magna Colorado. Although my review stick straightened itself out each time, there were areas in the first and second third where I was but moments away from cracking open that torch for a correction. My sample sticks performed slightly worse, with touch-ups on one cigar occurring in each section. 

However, smoke flow rates and textures were top-notch, and although there was some blooming in areas, the ash did not devolve into a flaky mess like certain cigars tend to do when uneven combustion comes calling. The oily texture to the smoke from beginning to end was especially solid, consistently creating a creamy mouthfeel and retrohale that never got beyond medium in body, spiciness, or strength.

Final Thoughts

Quesada "Casa Magna Colorado" Review 

Despite being what some may consider to be the old guard in the Quesada collection, the Casa Magna Colorado continues to earn a vigorous nod of approval every time I spark this blend up. I like the way it looks, even though it is most certainly not something unique in nature, and flavors and aromatics remain right on each time, with very little variation in delivery from stick to stick. 

Those fermented yogurt lassi tea tastes and herbal sub-notes add a whole other level of depth to this blend that bumps the whole smoke session into a different bracket, and these attributes are both satisfying and smooth in their delivery. The finish may fall a bit short at times, especially in the final third, but the aromatics that fill the air more than make up for this shortcoming. Smoke flow rates are also excellent, so if you want to produce billowy clouds, cut the cap with a guillotine instead of punching this one.

For my personal smoking preferences, I found the hardwood hickory tastes and smells to be extra appealing, and the way in which the start of the cigar stayed true to that backyard barbecue flavor for much of the first and second third. It's a stogie that has a good amount of sweetness and depth to it, and plenty of backing notes to form a degree of depth to keep you engaged, without going too heavy or intense on the tongue at any point. This, my friends, is why this premium cigar blend has gone virtually unchanged since its inception all those years ago, and why Klaro has made Quesada's crown jewel a permanent fixture in our portfolio.

Quesada "Casa Magna Colorado" Review

Flavor, Aroma & Transitions5.0
Depth & Complexity5.0
Construction, Burn & Physical Appeal4.0
Backstory & Branding4.0
Overall Balance & Repeatability4.5

Stogie Specs

CigarQuesada Cigars "Casa Magna Colorado"
WrapperShade-Grown Cuban-Seed (Nicaragua)
BinderNicaragua
FillerNicaragua
FactoryDominican Republic
Size5½″ x 52 (Robusto)
StrengthMedium
Pairing DrinkHomemade Honey Lemon Ginger Soda
Rating4.5/5
Get This CigarQuesada Casa Magna Colorado $44.69 $49.16
5.5" Length
52 Ring Gauge
Full Strength
Wrapper
Cuban-Seed Shade-Grown Colorado (Nicaragua)
Binder
Nicaragua
Filler
Nicaragua
Origin
Dominican Republic
About This Cigar

The Casa Magna Colorado Robusto 5½" x 52 is a medium-full-bodied Nicaraguan puro originally created through the collaboration of master blenders Manuel Quesada and Nestor Plasencia. Now produced in-house at Quesada's Dominican factory, this smoke features a distinctively reddish, shade-grown Cuban-seed Colorado wrapper over choice Nicaraguan binder and filler tobaccos. The classic Robusto format delivers a rich and flavorful smoking experience with plenty of depth that at one point earned it the #1 Cigar of the Year award at Cigar Aficionado.

As for flavor, this tobacco blend brings together a satisfying combination of cedar, coffee, cinnamon, and toasted notes, creating a bold yet complex profile from start to finish. With its rich Nicaraguan character and medium strength, the Casa Magna Colorado Robusto is a reliable, extremely rewarding choice for smokers looking for a flavorful, substantial cigar in a compact format.

View full details →
Quesada Casa Magna Colorado $44.69 View Cigar →

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.